POSTS
Above and Beyond
Thoughts on The Undoing Project by Michael LewisAlthough I’m neurotically driven to save much of Michael Lewis’ work for some optimal time in the future, one book has triggered this rainy-day mentality above the rest. Many readers consider The Undoing Project to be Lewis’ best work to date, so I, ever the rationalist, have avoided it.
It’s perverse, I know. I’m working on it. That’s why I finally put my foot down and started reading. That same foot is now kicking me for waiting so long.
In some ways, Lewis has it easy. To the extent that any topic can be called “inherently fascinating,” I think the Israeli psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman qualify. Their revelations on human decision-making heuristics somehow feel simultaneously relatable and surprising. It’s almost dizzying to read such apt descriptions of your own thought process, and it’s downright delightful to learn how the two proved their hypotheses. The success of Kahneman’s 2011 pop-sci book Thinking, Fast and Slow demonstrates the wide appeal of these ideas. Who among us could have guessed that the research obscured the truly moving story?
Not this Michael, that’s for sure. Lewis, though, seems to own the journalist’s equivalent of dowsing rod. Except instead of water, it’s calibrated for human interest…and instead of doing absolutely nothing, it actually works! Magnificently! (Okay, that analog might be SOMEWHAT forced, but I’ve written it, and I’m not turning back.)
Kahneman and Tversky are each fascinating in their own right, each highly intelligent and idiosyncratic. Their distinctive worldviews shape not only their contribution but also their perspective on the findings themselves. Together, they form the most unlikely team–maybe the only kind of union that could facilitate their work. Each breakthrough in that body of work fits satisfyingly into a larger framework, and their lived experience in an embattled Israel introduces themes of brutality and peril that one might not expect from a book about a couple of academics.
If you simply listed the facts, you’d end up with a compelling, substantial essay. Lewis did much more than list the facts.
Most obviously, he has a knack for metaphor. Sometimes he invents his own, while other times, he explains the events in terms of the psychology itself. After reading an extended, careful explanation of the intricacies of one study or another, it’s supremely satisfying when Lewis reveals the parallels to Tversky and Kahneman’s struggles.
Lewis also does a fantastic job surfacing the beauty of the researchers' collaboration…to the extent that outsiders can understand that dynamic at all. Beyond explicitly struggling with this intimate aspect of his subjects, Lewis reinforces it through subtle narrative choices, making only passing reference to major life milestones like marriage and childbirth. He doesn’t simply highlight the human angle (the irrational, the tragic, the absurd); he conveys it with the sensitivity and nuance it demands.
It feels strange to commend the “pacing” of a work of nonfiction (as if the journalist has creative control over the events), but there’s no denying Lewis' ability to reinforce a latent narrative without crossing the line into dramatization. It’s tough to articulate how he’s done it, though even I, a rambly book-report-writer, can recognize his skill in selective focus and his careful use of foreshadowing. It’s only with some effort that I imagine Lewis' research process because the result is so coherent. It all culminates in a referendum on the friendship itself, one which had me questioning my biases right alongside Kahneman and Tversky.
If they were here today, I’m sure the psychologists could explain all the subconscious heuristics that caused me to covet their biography for an entire decade. And before I actually picked it up, I would have been grateful if that was all they taught me. The Undoing Project proves that Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman’s extraordinary findings were actually the least of their lessons.